Learning to produce new sounds is rare. It turns up in a handful of unrelated groups — songbirds, parrots, hummingbirds, some whales and bats, humans — and each appears to have arrived at it separately.
Well supportedGood evidence backs this, though some details remain open.
Vocal production learning is documented in three avian clades (oscine passerines, psittaciformes, trochilidae) and several mammalian lineages (cetaceans, some chiropterans, pinnipeds, elephants, humans), distributed across the phylogeny in a pattern indicating multiple independent origins. Comparative neuroanatomy identifies a recurring correlate: a direct forebrain projection to the motor neurons controlling the vocal organ, absent in related non-learners.
- Who this applies to
- A comparative statement about the distribution of the trait, with sharply uneven evidence quality between the groups listed.
- Studied in
- Aves, Mammalia
Why we rate it this way, and what the caveats are
The phylogenetic pattern and the neuroanatomical correlate are both well established. The uncertainty is at the edges of the list rather than in its shape — several species show partial or contested abilities.
How far it can be extended
The behavioural demonstration is strong for songbirds, parrots, hummingbirds and humans, and rests on smaller or more indirect evidence for cetaceans, bats, pinnipeds and elephants.
Caveats
- Vocal learning is better described as a graded continuum than a binary; several species modify innate calls to a limited degree and whether they "count" depends where a line is drawn.
- Evidence quality is very uneven: extensive for songbirds, comparatively thin for bats, pinnipeds and elephants.
- A shared neural feature across independent origins may reflect a shared developmental constraint rather than a shared solution.
Still unanswered
- Whether limited call modification in some primates and other mammals belongs on the same continuum or is a different phenomenon.
Last reviewed 2026-09-02
The evidence (3 studies)
Supports · primary
Evolution of vocal learning and spoken language
Jarvis, 2019 · Science
The comparative synthesis, including the shared forebrain-to-motor-neuron projection across independently evolved learners.
Supports · supporting
Open-ended song learning in a hummingbird
Araya-Salas and Wright, 2013 · Biology Letters
Establishes learning in the third avian clade, and open-ended learning at that.
Supports · supporting
Vertical transmission of learned signatures in a wild parrot
Berg et al., 2012 · Proceedings of the Royal Society B
Cross-fostering in a wild parrot, which is the cleanest demonstration of learned vocal signatures in any non-songbird.