In most forests, the great majority of what plants make is never eaten by a herbivore. It dies, falls, and is dismantled — which is the pathway almost every food chain diagram omits.
EstablishedSpecialists would state this without hedging. Multiple independent lines of evidence agree.
Compiled production budgets show the proportion of primary production consumed by herbivores varying systematically across ecosystem types, from a small minority in structurally complex, slow-turnover vegetation such as forests to a large majority in phytoplankton systems. The unconsumed remainder enters the detrital pathway.
- Who this applies to
- Terrestrial and aquatic plant communities; the grazed fraction differs enormously between them.
- Studied in
- Plantae
Why we rate it this way, and what the caveats are
A large compilation with a consistent pattern, though individual production budgets are hard to measure and methods differ between the studies compiled.
How far it can be extended
Compiled across forests, grasslands, marshes, seagrass, macroalgae and phytoplankton.
Caveats
- Not universal: in phytoplankton systems most production genuinely is grazed, so this is a statement about forests rather than about life.
- Production budgets are compiled from studies with differing methods, and within-type variation is large.
Still unanswered
- How much the grazed fraction shifts under sustained herbivore change, which few systems have measured directly.
Last reviewed 2026-09-04
The evidence (2 studies)
Supports · primary
Patterns in the fate of production in plant communities
Cebrian, 1999 · The American Naturalist
The compilation of production fates across ecosystem types.
Supports · supporting
Detritus, trophic dynamics and biodiversity
Moore et al., 2004 · Ecology Letters
The structure of the food web that unconsumed production feeds.