Low sounds carry much further than high ones through air, vegetation and water. That physical fact, more than anything about the animals, explains who communicates at long range and who does not.
EstablishedSpecialists would state this without hedging. Multiple independent lines of evidence agree.
Atmospheric and aquatic attenuation increase with frequency, so low-frequency signals suffer less absorption and scattering over distance. Species communicating over kilometres — elephants, baleen whales, some birds in dense habitat — use correspondingly low fundamental frequencies, while short-range and high-resolution signals such as echolocation use high frequencies.
- Who this applies to
- A physical constraint on sound propagation, applying wherever animals signal acoustically.
- Studied in
- Animalia
Why we rate it this way, and what the caveats are
The physics is not in dispute, and the comparative pattern across unrelated long-range signallers is exactly what it predicts.
How far it can be extended
The frequency dependence of attenuation is a property of the medium, and the comparative pattern across long- and short-range signallers follows it closely.
Caveats
- Range is not the only pressure: low frequencies are harder to localise and harder for a small animal to produce.
- Habitat matters as much as frequency — dense vegetation and temperature gradients change everything.
- Comparative patterns of this kind are consistent with the physics rather than tests of it.
Still unanswered
- How much of the variation in signal frequency within a habitat is explained by transmission as opposed to by competition for acoustic space.
Last reviewed 2026-09-02
The evidence (3 studies)
Supports · primary
Infrasonic calls of the Asian elephant
Payne et al., 1986 · Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
The long-range case, discovered only once somebody recorded below human hearing.
Supports · supporting
Echolocation by insect-eating bats
Schnitzler and Kalko, 2001 · BioScience
The other end of the trade-off: high frequencies bought for resolution and paid for in range.
Supports · supporting
Sensory Ecology, Behaviour, and Evolution
Stevens, 2013 · Oxford University Press
The general treatment of transmission constraints on signal design.